COVID-19 Announcement
RE: ESSENTIAL SERVICES

United Legal Services Professional Corporation is an essential service, available for business, while operating in accordance with Order issued by the Premier of Ontario, and is practicing and encouraging social distancing measures for the safe health of all persons. Learn More [61] Essential services include professional and social services that support the legal and justice system;
[65] Professional services including lawyers and paralegals, engineers, accountants, translators.
Order of the Premier of Ontario | March 23 2020 8:00PM

 


Can a Husband Sue a Wife For Causing Injury?

As Per the Occupier's Liability Act and Case Law, Co-Occupiers of Premises, Such As a Landlord and Tenant That Share Common Areas Upon the Premises, Owe a Duty of Care to Each Other to Ensure That the Premises Is Kept Reasonably Safe.
A Brief Outline As a Helpful Guide on How to Determine and Understand Co-Occupier Liability Risks Involving the Occupier's Liability Act:

Lawsuit Document Involving Tort Law Issues In Ontario, the Occupier's Liability ActR.S.O. 1990, c. O.2 prescribes the duty of care owed by an occupier to those who may be upon premises occupied by the occupier.  The prescribed duties, with some exceptions, include concerns relating to legal liability for personal injuries or property damage that may arise due to the activities conducted upon the premises or that may arise due to the condition of the premises.  The Occupier's Liability Act includes legal principles that prescribe concerns relating to how the law should be applied for issues such as when injuries occur to a person who slips or falls due to slippery snow and ice conditions, among other things.  Specifically, the Occupier's Liability Act states:

Definitions

1 In this Act,

“occupier” includes,

(a) a person who is in physical possession of premises, or

(b) a person who has responsibility for and control over the condition of premises or the activities there carried on, or control over persons allowed to enter the premises,

despite the fact that there is more than one occupier of the same premises;

Occupier’s Duty

3 (1) An occupier of premises owes a duty to take such care as in all the circumstances of the case is reasonable to see that persons entering on the premises, and the property brought on the premises by those persons are reasonably safe while on the premises.

As is stated per s.1, an occupier is defined broadly and can include owners, tenants, contractors, among many others, who are in care and control of premises.  Furthermore, per s. 3, each occupier is prescribed a broad duty of care which is to act reasonably to ensure that other persons, and property of other persons, is reasonably safe while upon the premises.  With some exceptions, such as a limited duty owed to trespassers, such as criminals entering onto the premises for unlawful purposes, the duties owed to other persons remains quite broad.

Does a Tenant Owe a Duty of Care to a Landlord?

Yes, Co-Occupiers of Premises Do Owe a Duty of Care to Each Other In Accordance to the Occupier's Liability Act.

A question of concern that sometimes arises in law is whether an occupier owes a duty of care to another occupier of the same premises.  An example could include whether a contractor, as a person with care and control of premises when hired to perform snow clearing within the parking lot, is owed a duty of care by the janitorial staff whose job it is to shovel the sidewalk leading to the parking lot.  If the contractor snow became piled upon the sidewalk due to the plowing operations of the contractor, and that contractor subsequently (assumedly after a reasonable time) slips on ice on the sidewalk that is occurring from the melting of the snow plowed earlier by the contractor, and the ice being present due to failure of the janitorial staff to tend to the ice, can the janitorial staff be found as owing a duty of care to the contractor?  Another interesting example could be whether a landlord and tenant owe duties to each other.  In this scenario, imagine a residential dwelling occupied in part by a landlord and in part by a tenant; such as where the landlord is living within a unit upstairs and the tenant within a unit downstairs and both are sharing amentities such as the backyard patio, among some other 'common' areas.  In this scenario, did the landlord that leaves an obstacle upon the patio owe a duty of care to the tenant despite that the landlord and the tenant are co-occupiers of the patio?  How about the scenario where a husband of wife jointly own a home and the husband negligently leaves a waterspill on a floor leading to a slip and fall with injuries to the wife?

Recently, the Court of Appeal confirmed that co-occupiers may, and often do, owe a duty of care to each other.  Such was stated within the case of Nolet v. Fischer, 2020 ONCA 155 where it was expressly said:

[25]  To conclude, there is no language or provision of the Act that one occupier does not owe the duty of care to another occupier, or that provides that when an occupier enters on the premises they are not a person “entering on premises” for the purpose of the Act. Nor is there any basis to read any such legal restriction into the Act. While persons may enter onto premises for many different reasons and may leave quickly or stay indefinitely, the Act creates one duty that is owed to all such persons including those who are also other occupiers.

Summary Comment

Occupier liability prescribed by the Occupier's Liability Act includes a duty of care owed to other occupiers.  Accordingly, in law, although perhaps uncommonly occurring, an occupier such as a contractor hired to maintain premises may owe a duty of care to another contractor hired to maintain that same premise.  A landlord and tenant sharing a common area may owe a duty of care to each other to ensure that that common area is kept free of obstacles and thereby reasonably safe from causing injury to the each other.  A husband and wife, each jointly owning the same house, may owe a duty of care to maintain the house is such a manner as to avoid causing hazards that could injure the other.

United Legal Services provides litigation services for clients located in Markham, Brampton, Kingston, Oakville, Mississauga, among other places!

Fill out the form below to Arrange for a Consultation

Do not send confidential information through this website form.  This website is not intended to provide advice specific to your particular circumstances.  Use this website form only to arrange an introduction with a representative to discuss your particular circumstances.  Your IP Address is: 40.121.136.229

For more information, fill out the form below to send a direct inquiry to United Legal Services

ATTENTION: Confidential information regarding your case must not be sent through this website.  This website is not intended as providing legal advice nor intended as a method to establish a legal-representative/client relationship.  Do not include confidential details about your case by email or phone.  Use this website form only to arrange an introduction with a United Legal Services Professional Corporation representative, before taking any steps to discuss the particulars of your legal case.  Legal advice cannot be provided to you via reply email or over the phone.  Your IP Address is: 3.235.77.252
United Legal Services

3621 Highway 7 East, Suite 308
Markham, Ontario,
L3R 0G6

P: (647) 956-9258
E: gmaz@unitedlegal.ca

Hours of Business:

9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
Monday:
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:

By appointment only.  Please call for details.







Serving:

Markham
Newmarket
Hamilton
Oakville
Kitchener
North York
Kingston


Oshawa
Brampton
Greater Toronto Area
Peterborough
Ottawa
London
and much more


United Legal ServicesPROFESSIONAL CORPORATION

SSL Secured Trust https://unitedlegal.ca


Animated Spinner